The housing market has been explosive over the past yr, regardless of rising lumber costs, however latest knowledge suggests {that a} peak could also be in sight, which might be problematic for homebuilding ETFs.
On Wednesday, homebuilder confidence knowledge, as measured by the NAHB/Wells Fargo Housing Market Index, plummeted to a 13-month low in July, coming in at a studying of 75, versus projections for the index to stay regular at 80.
”Whereas the demographics and curiosity for homebuying stay stable, increased prices and materials entry points have resulted in decrease ranges of homebuilding and even put a maintain on some new house gross sales,” mentioned NAHB chief economist Robert Dietz.
”Whereas these supply-side limitations are holding again the market, our expectation is that manufacturing bottlenecks ought to ease over the approaching months and the market ought to return to extra regular situations,” he added.
The large rise within the value of lumber was a key issue within the spring. The price of constructing a house is because of quite a few components exterior of lumber, nevertheless.
As Dietz notes, supply-side limitations are nonetheless restraining housing, and it is turning into extra nebulous as to what might clear these impediments.
“Some potential consumers are experiencing sticker shock resulting from increased development prices,” mentioned NAHB Chairman Chuck Fowke, a homebuilder from Tampa, Florida. “Policymakers want to seek out long-term options to supply-chain points.”
The value of lumber has fallen dramatically since its peak earlier this yr. Lumber dropped 4.91% on Monday to shut at $470.90, its lowest degree since July 6, 2020. Lumber is down a large 72.48% from its intra-day excessive of $1,711.20 on Could 10.
“Whereas lumber costs are displaying enchancment, the value and availability of different constructing supplies stay a problem. These supplies embrace flooring, drywall, home equipment and home windows, mentioned the NAHB’s chief economist, Robert Dietz.
Mixture residential development materials pricing additionally elevated 13% within the first six months of 2021, per an NAHB evaluation of producer value index knowledge.
“Whereas the demographics and curiosity for house shopping for stay stable, increased prices and materials entry points have resulted in decrease ranges of house constructing and even put a maintain on some new house gross sales,” Dietz added, noting that his expectation is that manufacturing bottlenecks ought to ease over the approaching months and the market ought to return to extra regular situations.
Knowledge on enterprise inventories printed Wednesday revealed that producers proceed to generate gross sales at a swifter tempo than they’ll construct their backlogs, that means that demand is outstripping provide of supplies for homebuilders.
This might be problematic for housing ETFs just like the iShares DJ US Residence ETF (ITB), which fell 0.22% Wednesday, and the SPDR S&P Homebuilders ETF (XHB), which misplaced 0.17%.
Earlier within the yr, issues of elevated provide prices induced some analysts to foretell a possible recession.
“The actual fact is that if this continues, you will note the homebuilding sector decelerate and grind to a halt,” mentioned Jerry Howard, CEO of the Nationwide Affiliation of Homebuilders, who mentioned housing is commonly a number one indicator of financial well being. “This drawback with lumber and different constructing materials prices is type of setting one other potential good storm for housing to guide us right into a recession.”
A peak at second quarter GDP demonstrated a pointy decline in residential funding, with headline gross home product (GDP) progress failing to hit expectations. The most recent knowledge from S&P/Case-Shiller additionally revealed that house costs had been climbing at a document tempo as of Could; the following replace on this knowledge sequence is due later this month.
Whereas there are some issues that the rise in prices may end in a longer-term challenge for brand spanking new homebuyers, quite a few analysts see a extra predictable normalization within the housing market, the place costs start to degree out, and enthusiasm for brand spanking new mortgage functions fades.
”The story right here is easy, in our view,” writes Ian Shepherdson, chief economist at Pantheon Macroeconomics.
”[The] demand curve for single-family properties has moved again to the place it stood earlier than COVID, as a result of the preliminary impulse to flee cities for the burbs has light,” he wrote. “This course of seems to have nearly run its course, with mortgage functions regular in latest months, however the NAHB survey — together with the market and media narrative concerning the housing market — nonetheless must catch up.”
Over 56% of latest and present properties bought between the start of April and finish of June had been inexpensive to households incomes the U.S. median revenue of $79,900. It is a marked decline from the 63.1% of properties bought within the first quarter of 2021 and the biggest drop in affordability because the starting of the NAHB’s revised sequence within the first quarter of 2012.
If analysts are proper, this might imply that homebuilder ETFs just like the Direxion Each day Homebuilders & Provides Bull 3X Shares (NAIL) and the Hoya Capital Housing ETF (HOMZ) might have rocky waters forward.
For extra market traits, go to ETF Developments.
Learn extra on ETFtrends.com.
The views and opinions expressed herein are the views and opinions of the writer and don’t essentially replicate these of Nasdaq, Inc.