Trump suggests he would possibly “delay the election.” He can’t try this.

President Trump, dealing with cratering ballot numbers and the probability of an embarrassing defeat in November, instructed the nation ought to “Delay the Election” as a consequence of false fears of voter fraud:

Let’s deal first with Trump’s declare that “Common Mail-In Voting” will someway result in inaccurate or fraudulent outcomes. There isn’t a proof in anyway supporting this declare.

Common mail-in voting refers to a follow the place states mechanically mail a poll to all registered voters throughout the state — a poll that may then be forged by mail or returned in-person to varied polling websites. In response to the Brennan Middle for Justice, seven states — California, Colorado, Hawaii, Oregon, Utah, Vermont, and Washington — are vote-by-mail states.

Vote-by-mail isn’t a brand new follow. Oregon grew to become the primary state to undertake this follow in 2000. Since then, the state has supplied over 100 million mail-in ballots to voters since 2000. It has solely documented 12 circumstances of fraud.

In 2018, then-Secretary of Homeland Safety Kirstjen Nielsen, a Trump appointee spoke to Colorado election officers and effusively praised the vote-by-mail state as a mannequin of secure and safe elections. “We’d like to proceed to make use of you for example of what different states can undertake,” Trump’s homeland safety secretary instructed the Colorado election officers on the time.

So Trump isn’t merely utilizing false fears to justify delaying the November election — he’s utilizing false fears that his personal administration rejected as just lately as two years in the past.

Which brings us to the query of whether or not Trump can truly delay, and even cancel, the election. The quick reply to this query is “no.”

A trio of federal legal guidelines set Election Day for presidential electors, senators, and US representatives as “the Tuesday subsequent after the primary Monday in November.” If Republicans need to change this regulation, they would want to undergo the Democratic Home.

The 20th Modification, furthermore, offers that “the phrases of the President and the Vice President shall finish at midday on the 20th day of January.” Thus, even when the election had been someway canceled, Trump and Vice President Mike Pence’s phrases would nonetheless expire as scheduled — though, as defined under, the query of who would succeed them is devilishly sophisticated.

That doesn’t essentially imply that the November election is secure. Republican state governors and legislatures should still manipulate their very own election guidelines to offer a bonus to Trump. However Trump doesn’t have the lawful energy to delay or cancel an election.

Who will get to determine when an election is held?

There are totally different units of guidelines for congressional elections and presidential elections.

For congressional elections, the Structure offers that “the occasions, locations and method of holding elections for Senators and Representatives, shall be prescribed in every state by the legislature thereof; however the Congress might at any time by regulation make or alter such laws, besides as to the locations of selecting Senators.” Which means each Congress and state lawmakers have management over when a congressional election is held, however Congress has the ultimate phrase if there’s a disagreement.

Congress has set the date of Home and Senate elections for “the Tuesday subsequent after the first Monday in November.” Neither Trump nor any state official has the ability to change this date. Solely a subsequent act of Congress may accomplish that.

The image for presidential elections is barely extra sophisticated. A federal statute does present that “the electors of President and Vice President shall be appointed, in every State, on the Tuesday subsequent after the primary Monday in November,” so states should select members of the Electoral Faculty on the identical day as a congressional election takes place.

That mentioned, there may be technically no constitutional requirement {that a} state should maintain an election to decide on members of the Electoral Faculty. The Structure offers that “every state shall appoint, in such method because the Legislature thereof might direct, a variety of electors, equal to the entire variety of Senators and Representatives to which the State could also be entitled within the Congress.” So a state legislature may theoretically determine to pick presidential electors out of a hat. Extra worrisome, a legislature managed by one get together may probably appoint loyal members of that get together on to the Electoral Faculty.

But whereas state lawmakers theoretically have this energy, the concept presidents are chosen by well-liked election is now so ingrained into our tradition that it’s extremely unlikely any state legislature would attempt to appoint electors immediately. By 1832, each US state besides South Carolina used a well-liked election to decide on members of the Electoral Faculty. South Carolina got here round within the 1860s.

Furthermore, as soon as a state decides to carry an election to decide on members of the Electoral Faculty, all voters should be afforded equal standing. Because the Supreme Courtroom defined in Harper v. Virginia Board of Elections (1966), “as soon as the franchise is granted to the citizens, strains is probably not drawn that are inconsistent with the Equal Safety Clause of the Fourteenth Modification.”

Moreover, even when a state did determine to nominate electors immediately, that will require the state to enact a regulation altering its technique of choosing members of the Electoral Faculty. A number of essential swing states, together with Wisconsin, Michigan, Pennsylvania, and North Carolina, have Democratic governors who may veto such laws.

All of which is a great distance of claiming that the danger that an election shall be outright canceled — or {that a} state might attempt to take the ability to take away President Trump away from its individuals — is exceedingly low.

Okay, but when the election is canceled, what occurs then?

Let’s presume, for only a second, that the election doesn’t occur as scheduled, for no matter purpose. Who does that go away in cost? It seems that the reply to this query is surprisingly sophisticated, and it might activate whether or not at the very least one state manages to call people to the Electoral Faculty.

Buckle up. That is about to get actually deep into the constitutional weeds.

The 12th Modification offers that after the members of the Electoral Faculty are chosen, these electors shall meet and forged their ballots, and “the particular person having the best variety of votes for President, shall be the President, if such quantity be a majority of the entire variety of Electors appointed.”

It’s unclear what occurs if just some states maintain the presidential election as scheduled, whereas others fail to nominate electors in any respect, however the 12th Modification’s textual content (“a majority of the entire variety of Electors appointed”) means that the whole variety of electors wanted to decide on a president declines if some states don’t appoint anybody to the Electoral Faculty. If solely 100 electors are appointed, 51 electoral votes may probably be sufficient to decide on a president.

For sure, this quirk of the Structure’s textual content offers each state an incentive to carry their election. If a bloc of pink states delays the election, whereas blue states don’t, Republicans may successfully forfeit the Electoral Faculty vote.

However let’s say that nobody wins a majority of the electors. If that occurs, the ability to decide on a president falls to the Home — however with a twist. If the Home known as upon to decide on a president, it should select one of many three candidates who acquired essentially the most electoral votes. Furthermore, every state’s congressional delegation has just one vote, and “a majority of all of the states shall be essential to a alternative.”

Whereas Democrats have a considerable majority within the US Home as an entire, Republicans management a majority of the Home seats in 26 states — simply sufficient to decide on a president. That mentioned, this quantity may simply change. In lots of states, one get together controls just one or two seats greater than the opposite. If a handful of Home members are incapacitated as a consequence of coronavirus, that might probably alter the result of a Home vote to decide on the president.

Now let’s shift gears to a state of affairs the place no members of the Electoral Faculty are appointed. On this state of affairs, the Home can not select a president as a result of the 12th Modification requires it to select from among the many three candidates who obtain essentially the most electoral votes.

Below the 20th Modification, “the phrases of the President and the Vice President shall finish at midday on the 20th day of January, and the phrases of Senators and Representatives at midday on the 3d [sic] day of January.” So, if nobody is elected to exchange these officers, Trump and Pence stop to be elected officers the minute their phrases expire on January 20. Members of the Home serve two-year phrases, so all members of the Home will stop to be representatives on January 3; one-third of senators’ phrases additionally expire on that date.

Ordinarily, if the presidency and vice presidency are each vacant on the identical time, the workplace falls to the speaker of the Home. But when there isn’t a election, there shall be no speaker when Trump and Pence’s phrases expire as a result of all Home seats will turn into vacant on January 3.

If there isn’t a president, vp, or speaker, the subsequent official in line is the president professional tempore of the Senate, a largely ceremonial place that’s historically held by essentially the most senior member of the bulk get together. Proper now that’s Sen. Chuck Grassley (R-IA).

However wait! Recall that the phrases of many senators additionally expire on January 3. Because it seems, 23 seats held by Republicans and solely 12 seats held by Democrats are up for election this yr, so if no election is held, Democrats could have a majority within the Senate as soon as these seats turn into vacant. Which might imply that Senate Democrats would be capable to select a brand new president professional tempore. In the event that they observe the custom of selecting essentially the most senior member of their caucus, that will place Sen. Patrick Leahy (D-VT) subsequent in line for the presidency.

Issues truly get much more sophisticated from right here. The 17th Modification permits state governors to call short-term senators to vacant seats, however not all states permit their governors to take action. It’s additionally not instantly clear who can be the governor of many states if no election takes place in 2020, as a result of a lot of the road of succession in these states might be rendered vacant as nicely.

In any occasion, should you’ve learn this far, your eyes are in all probability glazing over by now. The quirks of presidential succession present fodder for constitutional legal professionals to chew over, however, on the finish of the day, the federal authorities’s energy flows from the consent of the individuals. We permit our leaders to control as a result of we belief that they’ve been chosen in a constitutionally legitimate course of. And we belief that course of as a result of it’s, at the very least, vaguely understandable.

If somebody begins calling themselves “president” as a result of they had been chosen by a subset of a Senate that’s lacking a 3rd of its members, a possible end result is civil unrest — particularly in a nation that’s already on edge due to the extraordinary measures wanted to examine the unfold of a pandemic.

Within the exceedingly unlikely occasion that the 2020 election is canceled, the outcome isn’t more likely to be an prolonged time period for President Trump. The probably result’s chaos.

---

Assist Vox’s explanatory journalism

On daily basis at Vox, we intention to reply your most vital questions and supply you, and our viewers around the globe, with data that has the ability to avoid wasting lives. Our mission has by no means been extra important than it’s on this second: to empower you thru understanding. Vox’s work is reaching extra individuals than ever, however our distinctive model of explanatory journalism takes assets — significantly throughout a pandemic and an financial downturn. Your monetary contribution is not going to represent a donation, however it can allow our workers to proceed to supply free articles, movies, and podcasts on the high quality and quantity that this second requires. Please take into account making a contribution to Vox at the moment.