A-level and GCSE outcomes: Stress mounts on ministers to resolve examination disaster

Stress is mounting on ministers to resolve the examination grades disaster with simply days to go earlier than GCSE outcomes are printed on Thursday.

They face calls to delay the outcomes, change the grading algorithm or use the grades estimated by academics, after complaints of unfair A-level outcomes.

It comes as Northern Eire mentioned it could use teacher-assessed estimates for GCSE outcomes this week.

The federal government has defended the method it used to find out grades.

NI Training Minister Peter Weir mentioned forward of GCSE outcomes day on Thursday it could scrap an algorithm that will have taken under consideration the previous efficiency of colleges.

College students throughout the UK weren’t capable of sit exams as regular this yr due to the coronavirus pandemic.

In England, 280,000 A-level outcomes have been downgraded from instructor’s assessments on Thursday, virtually 40% of the overall. In Wales, 42% of A-level outcomes predicted by academics have been lowered by the examination watchdog.

Scotland’s First Minister Nicola Sturgeon apologised over downgraded examination outcomes there and agreed to just accept assessments by academics.

Examination regulator Ofqual has confronted criticism over the statistical mannequin it used to determine the grades.

The federal government faces rising concern from Conservative backbenchers. Former Tory chief Sir Iain Duncan Smith mentioned the A-level algorithm must be deserted, with instructor assessments or mock examination outcomes used as a substitute.

Wimbledon MP Stephen Hammond mentioned Ofqual’s failure to publish an appeals course of for A-levels was a “shambles”. He advised BBC Breakfast a delay to GCSE outcomes could also be “one of the best factor to do within the brief time period”.

Tory MP for Poole Sir Robert Syms mentioned his personal son had seen his outcomes lowered from A*ABB to all Bs. He advised Instances Radio it was “terribly unfair” for outcomes to be decided by a pc algorithm.

Kate Inexperienced, Labour’s shadow schooling secretary, advised BBC Breakfast: “We’re now going into week three of this debacle. We knew about the issue in Scotland two weeks in the past, we find out about the issue final week with A-levels.

“Right here we’re simply two or three days away from GCSE outcomes and the federal government nonetheless hasn’t bought a grip on the issue.”

Labour has referred to as for teacher-assessed grades for use for A-levels in England and has mentioned the choice ought to stay open for GCSEs if related issues emerge.

Many college students are anticipated to enchantment, though there was confusion over the appeals course of after Ofqual withdrew its steerage for difficult outcomes inside hours of publishing it on Saturday.

New tips are nonetheless being drawn up by Ofqual, the Division for Training mentioned on Sunday night.

A spokesman mentioned lots of of hundreds of scholars had obtained a calculated grade to “allow them to progress” and the division needs “to construct as a lot equity into the appeals system as potential”.

Higher Manchester Mayor Andy Burnham mentioned he can be writing to Ofqual to start out authorized motion over the “deeply flawed” allocation of grades, the third authorized problem the examination regulator faces over this yr’s A-levels.

In the meantime, lots of of scholars held an illustration in central London on Sunday to protests in opposition to grades they consider have been unfairly awarded.

Media playback is unsupported in your machine

The Sixth Kind Faculties Affiliation (SFCA) mentioned it checked out 65,000 examination entries in 41 topics from sixth type faculties and located that grades have been 20% decrease than historic performances for related college students in these faculties.

It mentioned that this equated to “12,048 lacking grades” in these faculties alone.

For instance, in Biology, it discovered that 24% of sixth type school college students have been awarded a grade decrease than related college students in recent times.

The SFCA mentioned its evaluation of 41 topics had not discovered a single one the place the outcomes have been above the three-year common.

Ofqual states that its goal for A-level outcomes this yr was to make sure “nationwide outcomes are broadly just like earlier years”.

SFCA mentioned its analysis confirmed that Ofqual had “failed” to satisfy that “elementary goal” and the mannequin it used had “not solely failed to supply broadly related outcomes, however has in actual fact produced worse leads to each single topic”.

Invoice Watkin, chief government of the SFCA, mentioned Ofqual ought to “instantly recalibrate and rerun the mannequin to offer all college students with an correct grade”.

“Ought to this nonetheless fail to supply outcomes which might be broadly just like earlier years, college students must be awarded the grades predicted by academics (often known as centre assessed grades),” he mentioned.

Dr Mark Fenton, chief government of the Grammar Faculty Heads Affiliation, mentioned the outcomes had additionally been unfair to a few of its college students.

He advised the BBC that “an important injustice has been executed” with “totally baffling” outcomes for some college students with the “solely truthful consequence” being to just accept grades predicted by academics.

Three of Oxford College’s faculties – Worcester, Wadham and St Edmund Corridor – have confirmed that each one locations supplied to UK college students will probably be secured regardless of their A-level outcomes.

After exams have been cancelled because of the coronavirus pandemic, grades have been awarded utilizing a controversial modelling system, with the important thing elements being the rating order of pupils and the earlier examination outcomes of colleges and faculties.

Forward of GCSE outcomes as a result of be launched on Thursday, former Conservative Training Secretary Lord Kenneth Baker urged the federal government to delay the publication of grades till the scenario surrounding A-levels had been resolved.

“If you’re in a gap, cease digging,” Lord Baker mentioned.

Earlier than outcomes have been launched, the Division for Training introduced a “triple-lock”, which meant that college students might settle for the grade calculated by Ofqual, enchantment to obtain a “legitimate mock end result” or sit autumn exams.

The federal government introduced on Friday that faculties wouldn’t should pay to enchantment in opposition to examination grades.

In England, 36% of entries had grades decrease than their academics predicted and three% have been down two grades. An analogous scenario in Scotland noticed a U-turn by the federal government, which agreed to just accept instructor estimates of scores.

• ALHAN’S WORLD: Well being tricks to preserve you in good condition in these socially distanced occasions
• WAKE UP TO MONEY: Bracing for the Covid recession

Have your A degree outcomes been affected by this yr’s grading system?

In some instances your query will probably be printed, displaying your identify, age and placement as you present it, except you state in any other case. Your contact particulars won’t ever be printed. Please guarantee you’ve got learn our phrases & situations and privateness coverage.

Use this way to ask your query: